Choosing a marketing and advertising agency: what are the most common mistakes in decision-making?

(By Dino Dal Molin and Belen Gandolfo Screpante) Marketing experts, industry magazines, and keynote speakers have begun to identify a common base error that most companies make when choosing an advertising or marketing agency. Many companies focus on agencies that specialize in a specific area of advertising, media or marketing tools, rather than seeking more comprehensive and broader agencies that can offer a more comprehensive range of services.

The reality is that this is based on an exaggeration in the market between 2016 and 2021 where the boom of online marketing made everything focus on one area of communication, one medium, and one part of marketing, which is digital marketing. The most important skill a marketing and communication provider has today is their multi competencies to listen, organize, coordinate, plan, and co-create cross-actions (on-off-experience) with diverse teams.

It is understandable that companies want to hire an advertising agency that specializes in the area where they need the most notable help. For example, if a company needs help with online advertising, they may look for a specialized agency in digital advertising. However, this can lead to a limited focus on the advertising campaign, a short-sighted marketing view, and a neglect of other important aspects of advertising and marketing, especially a company's strategy.

Comprehensive and broader advertising and marketing agencies have the ability to offer services in a variety of advertising areas, such as online advertising, print advertising, television advertising, cross-media planning, public relations, and digital marketing content, spacing, promotions, activations, product placement, trade marketing, sponsoring, live shopping, etc. This allows the company to have a more complete view of their advertising campaign and to create a more effective and real marketing and media strategy.

In addition, comprehensive and broader advertising agencies usually have a larger team of marketing and advertising professionals with more competencies for interaction and coordination, which allows them to offer services in different areas of specialization. This means that there is a higher level of collaboration and experience, which can result in a more successful advertising campaign.

Another benefit of hiring a comprehensive and broader advertising agency is that they can offer customized solutions for the specific needs of the company. Instead of focusing on a single area, they can create an advertising strategy that takes into account all aspects of the company, such as its brand, target audience, and budget.

Here are some other common mistakes when choosing a company to co-create marketing and communication that can have a negative impact on their marketing results. Below are some of the most common mistakes that companies make when choosing an advertising agency and how to avoid them.

  • Not doing extensive research on the work process beforehand

One of the biggest mistakes companies make when choosing an advertising agency is not doing proper research on the work system beforehand. Before hiring an advertising agency, it is important to research their background, experience, and reputation. But fundamentally, how are their competencies for coordinating and co-creating. 

The best agency is the one that has teams capable of conversing, listening, and planning their client's actions. This may include reviewing their portfolio of previous work, reading reviews and testimonials from previous clients, and verifying their credentials.

 

Marketing and advertising are processes that take time, and companies often make the mistake of expecting immediate results. It's important to remember that the success of an advertising campaign cannot be measured in a short period of time. Companies should give enough time to the advertising agency to implement and execute the advertising campaign and measure its results.

  • Not measuring results or only having digital "metrics"

Measuring results is fundamental for any advertising campaign. Companies should measure the results of the advertising campaign to determine its effectiveness and make necessary adjustments in the future. This includes measuring ROI, sales growth, brand recognition, but also being mindful of how happy your team is, how satisfied your customers are, what the weighted distribution of your product looks like, the product return rate, the percentage of repeat customers, how many customers come from the shopping experience, how many are referred by another customer; these are much more important indicators than Instagram likes.

Miami también se queda con las Series Finales de Nascar en el 2026

(Por Maqueda y Maurizio) En 2026, Miami no será una ciudad: será un estadio global. Con el Mundial de Fútbol, Grand Prix de F1, Miami Open, Series NASCAR y más, el sur de Florida proyecta una inyección económica de USD $12.000 millones y audiencias multiculturales que redefinirán el sportainment. 

(5 Minutos de Lectura de alto valor estratégico) 

¿Por qué Miami es la capital de los rooftops 2025? ¿Cuáles son los top?

(Por Vera) Miami fue una de las primeras ciudades en América donde los rooftops se convirtieron en una tendencia popular, pero la idea no necesariamente se copió del modelo de Monte Carlo u otro lugar específico. La proliferación de rooftops en Miami fue parte de una tendencia global en la industria de la hospitalidad y el entretenimiento urbano, y una serie de condiciones hoy hacen que Miami sea la capital de los rooftops.

(5 minutos de lectura de alto valor)

Collabs estratégicas: ¿qué son y por qué son claves en toda empresa desde el 2024?

(Por Maurizio y Otero) ¿Cómo las alianzas innovadoras conquistan audiencias en Miami, LATAM y España. Por qué necesitas a un Head de Cultura para liderar este tipo de diferenciales y por qué hoy este tipo de estrategias, al igual que el crossing marketing, la integración de contenidos (product placement), la expansión de categorías y las experiencias phydigitales son el nuevo abc de toda marca.

(5 Minutos de Lectura de alto valor estratégico) 

El G20 2026 será en Miami: Trump elige su complejo turístico (si algo le faltaba a la ciudad para ser la nueva capital de Occidente, no solo de anglolatina, ya lo logró)

(Por Equipo de Geopolítica & Economía (Taylor-Molina-Maurizio)) La cumbre del G20 aterriza en Trump National Doral: Un enorme impulso económico. Donald Trump anunció que la cumbre de líderes del G20 2026 se celebrará en su complejo de lujo Trump National Doral (Miami), del 14 al 15 de diciembre. Todos los medios del mundo, (y las marcas e inversiones) necesitan más que nunca tener su base en Miami.

(Lectura de alto valor estratégico: 4 Minutos)

Asesinan a Charlie Kirk, aliado de Trump, en tiroteo durante evento en universidad de Utah: reacciones y claves del crimen

(Por Taylor-Molina) El gobernador Spencer Cox (Utah) califica el hecho como "asesinato político"; Trump ordena banderas a media asta y promete "justicia". La comunidad internacional está conmocionada. La paradoja es que tanto se dice que la derecha, los conservadores, los libertarios atacan a la prensa, hoy una vez más, todo pensador, esta vez un comentarista y miembro activo de los medios,  defensor de la familia,  del matrimonio, de las libres ideas, de la fé judeo cristiana, del respeto por la mujer,  por los niños, por la libertad, es asesinado.

(5 Minutos de lectura de alto valor estratégico) 

Empresas de Latam pierden US$ 287.000 Millones/Anual: error mortal, subestimar el marketing real (phydigital) en la era crossing (parte III)

(Por Maqueda, Maurizio y Otero) En 2025, mientras el mundo celebra la IA y el metaverso, LATAM comete un suicidio corporativo masivo: el 73% de sus empresas han eliminado stands, equipos de activación y presupuesto para OOH (publicidad exterior), creyendo que el “marketing digital” es la panacea (Datos: eMarketer). El resultado: marcas desangrándose en un océano de algoritmos, incapaces de conectar con humanos reales. Este artículo no es una crítica: es un plan de rescate. 

(Duración de lectura de valor: 5 minutos)