Penalty for Colombia or Red Card for Diving? A Moment for Reflection: Beyond Fanaticism in Futbol (Soccer)

(By Ortega with contributions from Maurizio). Soccer (Fubol), the sport that ignites passion and evokes intense emotions, finds itself at a crossroads. The recent controversy surrounding the penalty awarded to Colombia in their match against Argentina has sparked a debate that transcends mere fanaticism. Can our fervor for our teams blind us to the reality on the field? In this article, we will explore how fanaticism can cloud our judgment and how we can approach these situations from a more objective and analytical perspective.

Image description

The penalty was contentious for several reasons. To begin with, the VAR predominantly presented a static image of the contact, failing to delve into the context of the action. This, of course, distorted the referee's view, who ultimately awarded the penalty. Moreover, the video clearly shows Muñoz diving in response to the tackle from the Benfica player, with no evident foul taking place.

  • The initial audio review did not indicate a penalty, but later claimed that the lifted foot had brought down the opponent. The problem is that the video shows a significant gap in time between the Argentine player’s foot movement and the Chilean player’s jump, suggesting clear simulation—yet, let’s consider Scaloni’s perspective:

Although he tried to avoid discussing the referee's performance, the Argentine coach referenced the play that changed the match. “The five VAR officials saw a penalty, that’s it. I honestly don’t see a penalty, but soccer is a sport that requires awareness of your surroundings. What Muñoz did says it all; he doesn’t protest at any moment, but it’s welcome for his team,” he emphasized. “I told him that on the sidelines, and he laughed. It’s clear that the penalty influenced the match,” concluded Scaloni.

 

  • The critical questions arise: What do Colombian fans see when they view this play? What do Argentinians perceive? What does a Latino who dislikes Argentina or hopes for their loss observe? What does a Venezuelan rooting for Colombia's defeat see?

Watch the video here:

https://www.instagram.com/reel/C_ySHOVumDM/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

  • Now, the pressing inquiry is how the VAR perceived what it did. Will there be a review from CONMEBOL? And although it may not be FIFA's direct responsibility, can this incident serve as a lesson to ensure such blatant injustices do not recur?

  • What role does the press, whether Colombian, Argentine, or from elsewhere, play in these situations?

Frequently Asked Questions:

Why can fanaticism be detrimental to sports?
Fanaticism blinds fans, preventing an objective assessment of critical situations that may arise during the game.

How do referee decisions influence players' psychology?
Referee decisions can alter a team's confidence and performance, impacting their play throughout the match.

What role does technology, like VAR, play in game perception?
While VAR aims to enhance fairness in sports, its implementation has generated criticism and confusion, particularly at decisive moments.

  • The recent controversy surrounding the penalty awarded to Colombia highlights the need for a deeper analysis of how referee decisions and technology impact game performance and perception. With a focus on critical thinking, and bolstered by insights from neuroscience, this article aims to unravel the complexities of sports fanaticism and provide tools for a more critical and less emotional understanding of soccer.

The Context of the Penalty

During the match between Colombia and Argentina, a penalty awarded by referee Piero Maza after a VAR review sparked widespread indignation. The decision, which ultimately affected the outcome, was based on an interpretation of the foul committed by Nicolás Otamendi against Colombian Muñoz. The controversy intensified with the release of VAR audios, revealing the decision-making process behind this contentious call. Argentine coach Lionel Scaloni expressed his discontent, emphasizing that the penalty was decisive in an otherwise balanced game. This reaction reflects the frustration many fans feel when referee decisions impact the final result.

The Impact of Fanaticism

Fanaticism, in its purest form, is a manifestation of human passion. However, in sports, it can become an obstacle to objectivity. Often, fans become ensnared in an emotional spiral that impedes their ability to analyze the game clearly. This lack of objectivity can have repercussions not only for fans but also for players and referees.

The Psychology of the Fan

From a neuroscience perspective, fanaticism can be understood as a psychological phenomenon that activates specific brain circuits associated with reward and emotion. When a fan cheers for their team, their brain releases dopamine, the pleasure hormone. This phenomenon can lead to a form of “blindness” that hinders critical evaluation of complex situations, such as the disputed penalty.

The Influence of VAR

  • The use of VAR has been an attempt to introduce fairness into soccer, but its implementation has generated confusion and disagreement. The VAR audios from

the mentioned match reveal a process that may be perceived as arbitrary by fans. The question arises: how can a system designed to enhance fairness generate even more controversy?

The key may lie in perception. When fans witness a decision that contradicts their initial understanding of the game, they can react emotionally. This is particularly relevant in critical moments, such as a penalty that could determine the outcome of a match.

Advice for a New Perspective

Foster Empathy: Attempting to understand decisions from the perspective of referees and players can help mitigate frustration. Remember that referees are human and can also make mistakes.

Critical Analysis: Instead of reacting impulsively, it’s advisable to pause and analyze the situation from a more objective standpoint. Asking what the decisions mean for the overall game can provide a clearer view.

Education in Soccer: Promoting education about the rules of the game and the functioning of VAR can help fans better understand what happens on the field and why certain decisions are made.

  1. Will there be a review of the match, the outcome, the VAR process? 

  2. Will the international press and fans learn anything, or will everything continue as it has, tarnishing not only the sport but society as a whole?

  3. Will there ever be a gesture of apology from a national team, a referee, or a coach acknowledging that something was incorrectly called?

 

  • Registrate sin cargo, y recibe el newsletter solo dejando tu mail y nombre aquí.

  • Sign Up for Free: Register and receive our newsletter by simply leaving your email and name here. (https://infonegocios.miami/suscribite-al-newsletter)

  • IG: @infonegociosmiami

Infonegocios RED: 4.5 Millones de anglolatinos leyendo diariamente las noticias del mundo de los negocios

Infonegocios RED: 4.5 million Anglophone Latinos reading business news daily.

Contacts: marcelo.maurizio@onefullagency.com or juan.maqueda@onefullagency.com 

Tu opinión enriquece este artículo:

La nueva frontera del éxito 2025: ¿por qué la F1 está demostrando la nueva forma de hacer negocios? (crossing marketing, mega activaciones y expansión de categorías)

(Por M. Rodriguez Otero, junto a M. Maurizio) ¿Te preguntaste por qué algunas marcas están desarrollando mega acciones cruzadas de marketing y sólo ellas están logrando atrapar la mente y el corazón de sus consumidores? La respuesta está en algo que, en 2025, ya no es una opción: el crossing marketing y las mega activaciones multisensoriales.

(Lectura ágil de alto valor estratégico: 4 minutos)

Primero Botafogo, segundo… la noche en la que un gigante sudamericano desafió a París Saint-Germain y cambió el destino del Grupo B

(Una creación colaborativa de MotorHome, Red InfoNegocios, XDXT) ¿Alguna vez viste una noche que quedará en la historia del fútbol sudamericano y del Mundial de Clubes? La respuesta la tiene Botafogo, que en Pasadena, en un escenario emblemático como el Rose Bowl, no solo venció 1-0 al reciente campeón de la UEFA Champions League

(Contenido ágil: 4 minutos de lectura)

¿Por qué la película F1: The Movie y sus mega activaciones como la de Times Square están cambiando las reglas del juego? (la revolución del Crossing Marketing)

(Por Taylor desde NY, junto Maqueda & Maurizio) La película de la F1, acaba de invadir nada menos y nada más que las 5 esquinas, con autos, OOH, activaciones, ¿Alguna vez te has preguntado por qué ahora las campañas de marketing exitosas hacen muchísima más cosas?

(Contenido de alto valor estratégico: 4 minutos de lectura)

La Copa Mundial FIFA 2026 (y el mundial de clubes 2025): por qué son una revolución multiplataforma que transforman el ecosistema mediático-experiencial y de negocios global

(Por Maqueda, Taylor y Maurizio) ¿Qué si te dijera que la próxima Copa del Mundo no solo será un evento deportivo, sino un ecosistema mediático, cultural y comercial de alcance planetario?- Ya el mundial de clubes está siendo una prueba de ello y por supuesto la F1 ya lo es, y ¡con creces!. Lee esta nota porque todo cambió, y la mayoría de los medios no lo explican.

(Contenido de valor estratégico: 5 minutos)

Inter Miami avanza a octavos del Mundial de Clubes tras empate dramático con Palmeiras (desde el MotorHome… ¿Qué significa para los fans, los medios y el marketing este triunfo?)

(Una creación colaborativa de MotorHome, Red InfoNegocios, XDXT) Messi es la camiseta más vendida en USA, por lejos…, también la más codiciada hoy en Miami en medio del mundial de clubes. Adidas está feliz, el Inter Miami también, los argentinos orgullosos y los fans de las garzas sueñan a creer que es por el club.

Tiempo de lectura: 4 minutos

“Mission Crossing en Londres”: Brad Pitt y Tom Cruise en el estreno de "F1. The Movie" (unidos por la adrenalina de un nuevo mega evento)

(Por C.V. Otero desde Londres junto a Maqueda & Maurizio) ¿Alguna vez imaginaste que una película sobre Fórmula 1 podría desatar una lluvia de marcas, activaciones y de estrellas en Londres? El estreno de F1. The Movie ha congregado a Hollywood, al deporte, a la cultura, a las marcas  a  un mega evento que es consecuencia de lo ya hecho en México, NY y que marca la metodología del nuevo Marketing Crossing de las marcas y negocios exitosos.

 (Lectura ágil de 4 minutos)