Women are still less likely to aspire to leadership in business, despite decades of gender initiatives – we need to find out why

(Ekaterina Netchaeva, Bocconi University) The gender gap in pay, positions and even pensions for working women is well-established, but research shows that a gender aspiration gap has also emerged in recent years. This is when women do not aspire to rise through the ranks in the same way as men do, and it could affect efforts to encourage more women to apply for leadership roles at work.

Image description

The global drive to increase social equality in recent years has been led by ongoing research about how women are underrepresented in leadership roles throughout the business world. For example, recent research shows that while the share of women in senior management roles is increasing incrementally, the “leaky pipeline” effect means that fewer women reach the highest positions in companies.

This situation has compelled policy makers and business leaders to create diversity initiatives in an attempt to tip the balance. Afterall, research shows evidence of better financial performance among organisations with more women occupying senior roles, as well as the wider economic benefits of ensuring women can achieve their full economic potential.

These initiatives tend to focus on eliminating bias and are aimed at various stages – from recruitment to promotion. Some companies also design flexible work options such as the ability to work remotely. Creating a culture of inclusion and support can also help, for example, by implementing mentorship and advocacy programmes.

The goal of increasing women’s participation in leadership is undeniably well-intentioned. But when implementing these diversity initiatives, business leaders need to think about whether women even want to be in these leadership roles.

At the moment, many women actually do not aspire to be leaders, according to research I completed with Leah Sheppard of Washington State University and Tatiana Balushkina from the University of Milan-Bicocca. Our meta-analysis of research comparing men’s and women’s aspirations for leadership and managerial roles shows men are significantly more likely to aspire to leadership roles than women. We looked at six decades of research with a final sample of more than 138,000 US participants. We also created a simulation based on these results, which revealed that, in a company with eight hierarchical levels, the gender difference in leadership aspirations translates into having 2.13 men for every woman at the highest organisational level.

The difference in aspirations emerges around college age, according to our research. This is a time when many people gain their first taste of working life, through an internship or summer job for example. We also found that industry matters. The gender aspiration gap can certainly be seen in female-dominated fields such as nursing and education, but it is much larger in more mixed and male-dominated fields, such as politics and business.

Even as the number of diversity initiatives has increased, especially in the last decade, our meta-analysis shows the gender difference in leadership aspirations has remained the same over the past 60 years. This could suggest that, either current diversity initiatives do not address women’s concerns around these roles, or that the initiatives are too general and need to be more tailored to women’s specific needs.

Making it work

Our research indicates that company diversity initiatives are not working. So, business leaders and managers must do a better job of factoring women’s actual aspirations into the development of these initiatives. A good start would be to try to understand the specific reasons behind female employees’ lower aspirations, especially in male-dominated environments.

Although we were not able to test an explanation for the aspiration gap, we believe that it may have to do with the process of “self-stereotyping”. This is when individuals internalise gender stereotypes, voluntarily conforming to gender norms. For women, this can mean internalising a more communal stereotype, which leads them to view themselves as less similar to a leader. Unsurprisingly, such women do not tend to aspire to leadership positions. Men, on the other hand, may internalise the masculine “agentic” stereotype, which makes them think they can have greater control over themselves and others – this also aligns with the stereotypical idea people often have of leaders.

Of course, other explanations are possible. This could include women having more negative experiences in the workplace such as bias and discrimination, which puts them off aspiring to leadership roles. It is also possible that women are concerned that accepting a leadership position and the responsibility that comes might negatively affect their family lives. For example, women often hold more power when it comes to decision making at home – so much so, that they have less interest in gaining workplace power.

Women in glasses speaking to other women at a table in a meeting room

Any attempt to bolster women should start with specific and targeted interventions such as developing mentorship schemes or highlighting role models. Organisations should also focus on women who exhibit leadership potential early in their careers and provide them with useful resources and support to progress upwards through the organisation. Our results suggest that interventions aimed at increasing women’s leadership aspirations should ideally occur before or during college. Women at this stage in their careers might especially benefit from having the opportunity to see and interact with women that already occupy leadership roles.

It is possible to create gender diversity initiatives that will do more to increase the number of women reaching the upper echelons of business. And making space for more women to move into leadership positions is not only fair, it could also have a positive impact on company performance.

Ekaterina Netchaeva, Assistant Professor, Bocconi University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Tu opinión enriquece este artículo:

Todos los campeones del Mundial de Clubes: ¿sabes qué equipos la han ganado más veces? (una copa con absoluta hegemonía española)

(Una creación colaborativa de MotorHome, Red InfoNegocios, XDXT) La competencia que define al club más grande del mundo: historia, datos y análisis estratégico. La Historia de los Reyes del Fútbol Mundial.Desde su inicio en 2000, el Mundial de Clubes de la FIFA ha consolidado su lugar como la máxima competición intercontinental, heredera de la mítica Copa Intercontinental, que desde 1960 enfrentaba a los campeones de Europa y Sudamérica. 

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos

Dónde ver gratis la final del Mundial de Clubes 2025 (transmisión histórica y revolucionaria del streaming deportivo, para la que DANZ invirtió 1000 millones de dólares)

(Por Maurizio y Maqueda en una creación colaborativa de MotorHome y XDXT) ¿dónde podrán los seguidores ver estos partidos de manera gratuita, legal y en alta calidad? La respuesta marca un cambio radical en la forma en que consumimos el fútbol global. Gracias a la plataforma de streaming DAZN, este año la transmisión del torneo, por primera vez en la historia, gratis, como nunca antes. 

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos 

Chelsea vs. PSG son los finalistas del Mundial de Clubes 2025 (fecha, horario, sede, estadísticas y todo lo que debes saber)

(Por Creación colaborativa de MotorHome, Red Infonegocios y XDXT) La gran final del nuevo Mundial de Clubes, un evento que trasciende el fútbol. Ambos equipos, tras eliminar a sus rivales en semifinales, se preparan para disputar la gloria en un evento que combina deporte, espectáculo, experiencias crossing y un despliegue de marketing y entretenimiento al estilo Super Bowl. 

Duración de lectura: 5 minutos 

Tampa (Florida): ¿sabías que está cambiando totalmente su downtown para ser una ciudad del futuro?

(Por Taylor y Vera) Tampa no solo mira hacia el futuro, ¡lo construye! Un ejemplo de como un plan estratégico creado por los mejores talentos fuera del sistema gubernamental y la decisión de salir de la burocracia y el estatus quo, cambian ciudades. En 2019, la alcaldesa Jane Castor lanzó la visión Transforming Tomorrow, una hoja de ruta que busca convertir a Tampa en una ciudad más inclusiva, moderna y resiliente.

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos

¿Por qué Coquina Beach es el destino más bello para visitar en Florida y EEUU en 2025? (seguro no lo conocías)

(Por Vera) En un mundo donde la belleza natural y la experiencia auténtica se convierten en los principales reclamos turísticos, Coquina Beach emerge como un destino imprescindible en Florida y en todo Estados Unidos en 2025. ¿Qué hace a esta playa tan especial? ¿Por qué cada vez más viajeros, inversionistas y amantes del deporte y la cultura la consideran el paraíso escondido del sur de Florida? 


Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos 

¿Qué es el Storybeing y cómo revoluciona el marketing en la era de las experiencias phygitales y crossing? (parte II)

La evolución de las historias en el marketing. Desde los orígenes del storytelling, las marcas han buscado conectar con sus audiencias a través de historias, acciones y experiencias. Pero en un mundo donde la tecnología y la innovación transforman rápidamente cómo interactuamos, surge un nuevo concepto que va más allá de contar o vivir historias: el Storybeing. 

Duración de lectura: 5 minutos 

Turismo Internacional en Florida, Miami y Orlando: ¿Cuál es el plan en marcha para superar los desafíos y seguir creciendo en el 2025?

(Por Vera) Florida, Miami y Orlando han sido durante décadas el destino predilecto de millones de turistas internacionales, impulsando la economía, generando empleos y posicionando a EE.UU. como uno de los principales polos turísticos del mundo. Sin embargo, en los últimos años, diversos factores están poniendo a prueba la resiliencia de esta industria.

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos