Journalists are being overshadowed by influencers (when it comes to reaching the audience with informative topics) on social media platforms like TikTok and Snapchat (Part Two)

(Special Report by InfoNegocios Miami and Marcelo Maurizio) Teenagers and young people, 68% of them, no longer listen to news on the radio, not even on digital radios. They don't read it either. They only occasionally read news on digital written media. They don't watch in-depth interviews on TV or follow journalism programs or journalists. They also don't watch long videos on YouTube. The 2023 version of the Digital News Report by Reuters, published on the first Tuesday of June, analyzes news consumption trends worldwide.

Image description

The tremendous loss of attention span, concentration, patience, and focus goes beyond an intellectual matter. Not sitting down to do a single task that requires attention, concentration, reading, or following something that is not a shock of new things in 10 seconds or less, as IG or TikTok demands, makes humans emotionally more anxious, unstable, easily frustrated, and causes a myriad of relationship problems.

The brain starts to crave instant gratification and, even worse, believes that everything it is told is already true.

Journalists are trailing behind influencers when it comes to driving conversations about news on TikTok and other younger social media platforms. News performs well on Facebook and Twitter but lags behind on the rest. Despite its decreasing relevance, Facebook remains the most important social media platform for information.

More valuable information from the report:

One of the most surprising conclusions is that while journalists often lead conversations about news on Twitter and Facebook, they struggle to capture attention on newer platforms like Instagram, Snapchat, and TikTok, where celebrities, influencers, and ordinary people are often more prominent, even when it comes to news discussions, according to the researchers' comments.

The study, which surveyed about 94,000 adults from 46 markets earlier this year, revealed that "news" outperformed "celebrities" (influencers and famous personalities) on Facebook and Twitter. However, the latter group prevailed on TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat, and YouTube.

Some traditional media outlets have made their way into TikTok. NPR's Planet Money, for example, created a successful TikTok account by engaging in the comments and turning one of their professionals into the star of their videos.

But these are more exceptions than the rule, as the Reuters report highlights the persistent concern among publishers regarding the lack of solid monetization options and TikTok's connections with China.

Journalists may also find that the format of some of the newer social media platforms makes it difficult to build an audience. While they can use text and links to promote their work on Facebook and Twitter, they must learn to navigate video formats to participate on TikTok.

Although TikTok was the fastest-growing platform in the Reuters report, Facebook remained the most significant overall, with 28% of consumers using it to get news in the past week. This figure represents a 14-percentage-point drop from its peak of 42% in 2016.

"Facebook has been distancing itself from news for some time, reducing the percentage of news people see in their feed (3% according to the company's latest figures as of March 2023). Over the past year, it has also been reducing direct payments to publishers and other schemes that support journalism," emphasized the researchers.

Competition itself is driving Facebook to either change or perish... "tens of millions will be lost" in the coming years if the social network does not reform itself.
YouTube ranked second with 20%, followed by WhatsApp (16%), Instagram (14%), Twitter (11%), TikTok (6%, up from 1% in 2020), Messenger (6%), and Snapchat (2%).

And the researchers add, "Although the average usage for TikTok is relatively low, it is much higher among younger age groups, as well as in some Asia-Pacific, Latin American, and African countries."

The Reuters report also identifies differences in the topics that resonate on different social media platforms, which could hinder the efforts of journalists and media outlets to penetrate all of them with the same content.

"Twitter users are more likely to pay attention to hard-hitting topics like politics and business news, while users of other platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook are slightly more inclined to consume entertaining posts related to current events," the study states.

The challenge of discerning accurate information solely through the use of apps.

The use of social media platforms and applications presents challenges in evaluating the truthfulness and reliability of information. Here are some associated problems:

  • Dissemination of misinformation: Social media platforms and apps provide fertile ground for the spread of false and misleading information. The lack of verification and quality control can lead to the massive dissemination of fake news.
  • Cited research: Stanford University study on the spread of misinformation on social media (Vosoughi et al., 2018).
  • Confirmation bias: Social media platforms and apps tend to display content based on personalized algorithms, which can reinforce existing beliefs and
  • opinions, limiting exposure to different perspectives.
  • Cited research: University of Michigan study on confirmation bias in the use of social media (Nguyen et al., 2020).
  • Lack of context and depth: The brevity and fragmented nature of content on platforms like TikTok can make it challenging to obtain complete and accurate information. The lack of context can lead to misinterpretations or oversimplifications.
  • Cited research: University of California research on the impact of message brevity on information comprehension and retention (Diemand-Yauman et al., 2011).
    Recommendations to address these problems:
  • Promote media literacy: Foster education and awareness about critically evaluating information in digital environments, teaching individuals to identify reliable sources and verify information's truthfulness.
  • Develop critical thinking skills: Empower individuals to analyze and question the information they consume, considering multiple perspectives and evidence before forming opinions or sharing content.

Promote diverse sources:

  • Encourage seeking and accessing diverse sources of information, including reliable media outlets, academic research, and field experts.
  • Encourage platform responsibility: Urge social media platforms and apps to implement measures to reduce the spread of misinformation and improve transparency in the algorithms used to display content.
  • Strengthen collaboration between journalists and influencers: Foster collaboration between journalists and social media influencers to ensure the dissemination of accurate and verified information.

Key guidelines for using and consuming digital content products for all ages:

  • Reading, whether on digital or paper media, remains crucial for intellectual development and access to information.
  • The excessive use of social media platforms and apps presents challenges in terms of distraction and evaluating the truthfulness of information.
  • It is essential to promote media literacy and critical thinking to address these issues and ensure that the public can access reliable and quality information in the current digital environment.

References:

  1. Rideout, V., Starr, R., & Sweeney, D. (2018). The Common Sense Census: Media Use by Kids Age Zero to Eight 2017. Common Sense Media.
  2. Mangen, A., Walgermo, B. R., & Brønnick, K. (2019). Reading linear texts on paper versus computer screen: Effects on reading comprehension. International Journal of Educational Research, 88, 48-61.
  3. Reyna, J., Niederhauser, D., & Schraw, G. (2021). Interactive digital text: A review of the research. Computers & Education, 161, 104042.
    McAlone, N. (2023). "Influencers surpass journalists as news sources on TikTok and other popular social media platforms." Business Insider. Retrieved from:
  4. Baron, N. S. (2015). Words Onscreen: The Fate of Reading in a Digital World. Oxford University Press.
  5. Vosoughi, S., Roy, D., & Aral, S. (2018). The spread of true and false news online. Science, 359(6380), 1146-1151.
  6. Nguyen, T., Hua, J., & Wang, J. (2020). Information, Misinformation and Media Effects. Annual Review of Psychology, 71, 105-128.
  7. Diemand-Yauman, C., Oppenheimer, D. M., & Vaughan, E. B. (2011). Fortune favors the bold (and the italicized): Effects of disfluency on educational outcomes. Cognition, 118(1), 111-115.

Tu opinión enriquece este artículo:

Todos los campeones del Mundial de Clubes: ¿sabes qué equipos la han ganado más veces? (una copa con absoluta hegemonía española)

(Una creación colaborativa de MotorHome, Red InfoNegocios, XDXT) La competencia que define al club más grande del mundo: historia, datos y análisis estratégico. La Historia de los Reyes del Fútbol Mundial.Desde su inicio en 2000, el Mundial de Clubes de la FIFA ha consolidado su lugar como la máxima competición intercontinental, heredera de la mítica Copa Intercontinental, que desde 1960 enfrentaba a los campeones de Europa y Sudamérica. 

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos

Dónde ver gratis la final del Mundial de Clubes 2025 (transmisión histórica y revolucionaria del streaming deportivo, para la que DANZ invirtió 1000 millones de dólares)

(Por Maurizio y Maqueda en una creación colaborativa de MotorHome y XDXT) ¿dónde podrán los seguidores ver estos partidos de manera gratuita, legal y en alta calidad? La respuesta marca un cambio radical en la forma en que consumimos el fútbol global. Gracias a la plataforma de streaming DAZN, este año la transmisión del torneo, por primera vez en la historia, gratis, como nunca antes. 

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos 

Chelsea vs. PSG son los finalistas del Mundial de Clubes 2025 (fecha, horario, sede, estadísticas y todo lo que debes saber)

(Por Creación colaborativa de MotorHome, Red Infonegocios y XDXT) La gran final del nuevo Mundial de Clubes, un evento que trasciende el fútbol. Ambos equipos, tras eliminar a sus rivales en semifinales, se preparan para disputar la gloria en un evento que combina deporte, espectáculo, experiencias crossing y un despliegue de marketing y entretenimiento al estilo Super Bowl. 

Duración de lectura: 5 minutos 

Tampa (Florida): ¿sabías que está cambiando totalmente su downtown para ser una ciudad del futuro?

(Por Taylor y Vera) Tampa no solo mira hacia el futuro, ¡lo construye! Un ejemplo de como un plan estratégico creado por los mejores talentos fuera del sistema gubernamental y la decisión de salir de la burocracia y el estatus quo, cambian ciudades. En 2019, la alcaldesa Jane Castor lanzó la visión Transforming Tomorrow, una hoja de ruta que busca convertir a Tampa en una ciudad más inclusiva, moderna y resiliente.

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos

¿Por qué Coquina Beach es el destino más bello para visitar en Florida y EEUU en 2025? (seguro no lo conocías)

(Por Vera) En un mundo donde la belleza natural y la experiencia auténtica se convierten en los principales reclamos turísticos, Coquina Beach emerge como un destino imprescindible en Florida y en todo Estados Unidos en 2025. ¿Qué hace a esta playa tan especial? ¿Por qué cada vez más viajeros, inversionistas y amantes del deporte y la cultura la consideran el paraíso escondido del sur de Florida? 


Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos 

Turismo Internacional en Florida, Miami y Orlando: ¿Cuál es el plan en marcha para superar los desafíos y seguir creciendo en el 2025?

(Por Vera) Florida, Miami y Orlando han sido durante décadas el destino predilecto de millones de turistas internacionales, impulsando la economía, generando empleos y posicionando a EE.UU. como uno de los principales polos turísticos del mundo. Sin embargo, en los últimos años, diversos factores están poniendo a prueba la resiliencia de esta industria.

Tiempo de lectura: 5 minutos

¿Qué es el Storybeing y cómo revoluciona el marketing en la era de las experiencias phygitales y crossing? (parte II)

La evolución de las historias en el marketing. Desde los orígenes del storytelling, las marcas han buscado conectar con sus audiencias a través de historias, acciones y experiencias. Pero en un mundo donde la tecnología y la innovación transforman rápidamente cómo interactuamos, surge un nuevo concepto que va más allá de contar o vivir historias: el Storybeing. 

Duración de lectura: 5 minutos